“The strength of [The Best of the Best American Poetry] is its sense of subjectivity, the way these poems illustrate their editor’s aesthetic, and in so doing, tell us something of how poetry operates in the world…These are poems that take the personal and make it universal, not by grand statements but by specific observation, building a common vision out of the very things that hold us apart.”

– David Ulin, Los Angeles Times

“The Best of the Best American Poetry collects 100 splendid works by American poets from a quarter-century of the Best American Poetry series.”

– Colette Bancroft, Monterey County Herald

“A concentrated, high-caliber, and exhilarating overview of the intensity and artistry that have made American poetry so splendidly varied and vital…This is an anthology of broad scope, serious pleasure, and invaluable illumination.”

– Donna Seaman, Booklist

“This indispensable volume, with its rich mix of voices, forms and techniques, serves as a melting pot of contemporary American verse.”

– Julie Hale, BookPage

“It takes special chutzpah and perspective to pick the poems that deserve to make the best cut twice—and Pinsky’s fine collection proves that he’s got the chops to do it…His selection is so rich and diverse one can’t help but find several poems that will brighten any winter day…The Best of the Best American Poetry is a collection that never stops bringing light.”

– Bruce Jacobs, Shelf Awareness

“[A] survey of the past quarter-century of American verse…No doubt, some readers will discover new favorites here.”

– Publishers Weekly